Noah Kahan has spent the past year telling lawmakers that scalpers are the problem. On Tuesday, his own fans ran into a different one.
The presale for Kahan's 2027 The Last of the Bugs World Tour, a Live Nation-promoted stadium run across North America and Europe, opened with plenty of seats priced between $300 and more than $500 before a single reseller had touched them, according to fan screenshots compiled by TicketNews. Some buyers in New Jersey and Ohio said they were walking away.
Kahan's presale is the latest flashpoint in a complaint that has followed live music all year. Box offices are setting records, a jury has branded Ticketmaster a monopoly, and lawmakers in several states are writing resale caps. Yet a growing share of fans say the problem starts at the first price they see, not the second one, and that they are being quietly shown the door.
Kahan sits at the center of that tension. He is the most visible artist behind Massachusetts' push to cap resale at 110% of face value. Tuesday sharpened the critique that has trailed that campaign from the start: a resale cap limits what scalpers can charge, but nothing limits what the artist, promoter and Ticketmaster charge first.
What fans saw at checkout
The loudest complaints came from fans who already bought once. Kahan's July 18, 2026 show at Citi Field was canceled, and those ticket holders got first crack at the June 18, 2027 date at MetLife Stadium in a 9-11 a.m. ET window Tuesday. That window guaranteed access, not the same seats or the same price.
One fan, posting as @getawaycarvic on X, shared screenshots of a Section 10, Row 17 seat at $371.75 and Section 140 seats at $336.50, both including fees but not tax. A later post showed a "Front Porch" early-entry option at $583.15, and a checkout where a $405.50 ticket climbed to $513.09 after $81.10 in fees and $26.49 in tax. Those are different products and locations, not one seat rising in price, but they show what fans were being asked to pay. Others in the replies said the seats they landed at MetLife were noticeably worse than what they'd held at Citi Field.
The picture wasn't uniform. Some fans found upper-level seats for roughly $80 to $115, and some said prices looked similar to Kahan's last tour. Inventory tracker TicketVision posted these first-release ranges:
Show | Price range | Notes |
|---|---|---|
Ohio Stadium, Columbus (June 5) | $84-$714 | 45,497 tickets in first release |
Raymond James Stadium, Tampa | $88-$717 | |
MetLife Stadium, East Rutherford (June 18) | $80-$727 |
TicketVision's figures are its own observations of initial inventory, not confirmed sales, and TicketNews says it hasn't independently verified them.
Demand still looks strong. MetLife now lists a second night on June 19, which wasn't in its October 29 announcement, and Fenway Park added June 21 and 22, taking Kahan to six nights in Boston.
Kahan's position
As of Tuesday afternoon, Kahan had not publicly addressed the prices. His on-record stance on ticketing comes from July, when he stood with Massachusetts Gov. Maura Healey behind the proposed Great Divide Act, named for his album. The bill would generally cap concert resale at 110% of the original price, restrict resale marketplace fees and ban certain deceptive sales practices.
"I love my fans and want to protect them however I can," Kahan said in a statement released by Healey's office. He argued that artists can't stop secondary-market manipulation on their own without government help. Other New England musicians lined up behind the bill. He has pushed similar reforms in his home state of Vermont.
He has also put that philosophy into his own ticketing. The 2027 tour runs on Ticketmaster's Face Value Exchange, which locks resale at the original purchase price and generally bars transfers where the law allows. On his previous run, The Great Divide Tour, Kahan sold $100 "Front Porch" general-admission pit tickets through a registered presale, pitching them as a way to get fans into the best spots cheaply, Parade reported. On Tuesday, a Front Porch early-entry ticket showed up at $583.15.
A record year for the box office, a lonely one for fans
Kahan's fans aren't the only ones feeling left behind. By the industry's own numbers, live music is booming. Pollstar counted 12.5 million tickets sold by the top 100 touring artists in the first quarter of its 2026 chart year, up 4.8%, with gross up 15.7% to $1.36 billion. The average ticket hit $108.63, up 10.4% from $98.40 a year earlier, though still below the $123.25 peak of 2024, Pollstar reported.
Those averages hide the experience at the top of the market, where stadium headliners like Kahan live. In May, CNBC reported that higher ticket prices, rising gas costs and a broader pullback in discretionary spending were pricing many fans out, stoking fears that the cheap end of the concert market could fall away. One 29-year-old fan told the network a $500 nosebleed seat had become commonplace for the artists she wanted to see, and she was spending her money on cheaper shows instead.
Survey data points the same way, with a twist. Luminate's June 2026 live music report found more U.S. listeners rating concerts a good or great value, 78% in early 2026 versus 73% in mid-2024. But it also found the share of Millennial, Gen X and Boomer concertgoers naming ticket cost as a barrier ticked back up from late 2025 to early 2026. Fans still love the shows. More of them are deciding they can't go.
Kahan's own history fits the pattern. During the presale for his 2026 Great Divide run, fans who'd heard about $100 Front Porch tickets reported lower-bowl seats near $1,000 at Madison Square Garden, according to a February op-ed in the Daily Cardinal, the University of Wisconsin student paper.
The primary-market blind spot
The sharpest jab came from Tommy Dorfman, CEO of Juice Entertainment and a long-running Live Nation antagonist. He tagged Healey on X and said fans were being priced out before resale even enters the picture. Dorfman has litigated against Live Nation for more than a decade over a blocked Meadowlands EDM festival, allegations the company disputes, and recently filed Tunney Act comments opposing the DOJ's proposed antitrust settlement with Live Nation and Ticketmaster.
His point lands on the core design problem. The Great Divide Act caps the secondary market and leaves the primary market alone. An artist, promoter and ticketing partner can set the original price at $300, $400 or more, and can keep releasing differently priced inventory as demand shifts. The fan who bought that ticket has far fewer moves.
Face Value Exchange shows how. The listing price is fixed at what the buyer paid, fees and taxes included, and sellers can't raise or lower it. A fan stuck with a $500 ticket can't discount it on Ticketmaster's exchange if demand softens or they just want some money back. There are outs: the MetLife listing also authorizes CashorTrade, which allows below-face listings, and states including New York, Illinois, Colorado, Virginia, Utah and Connecticut limit how far issuers can block transfers. But compared with an open resale market, the options are narrow, and the issuer controls more of the ticket's life after the sale.
Supporters counter that face-value limits kill the scalper's margin and keep tickets circulating at their original price, which is exactly what artists like Kahan want. Neither side is wrong about its half of the problem.
Kahan has been here before
This is a rerun. In September 2023, during the presale for the We'll All Be Here Forever Tour, fans hit Ticketmaster Platinum prices of roughly $150 to more than $500 while transfers were restricted, TicketNews reported at the time. The same question came up then: why can the original price float while the resale price can't?
It's not clear yet whether dynamic or Platinum pricing was switched on for this week's presale. The screenshots show high prices, not the mechanism behind them.
The courts haven't touched the sticker price
Fans looking to Washington for relief have gotten verdicts, not discounts. On April 15, a Manhattan federal jury sided with more than 30 states and D.C., finding that Live Nation and Ticketmaster held an illegal monopoly over major concert venues and that Ticketmaster overcharged consumers $1.72 per ticket in 22 states, the AP reported. Jurors also saw internal messages in which a Live Nation employee, now a ticketing executive, joked about "robbing them blind." A remedies phase, which could include divestitures, is still ahead.
The federal government took a softer route. In March, the Justice Department settled its side of the case without forcing a breakup. The deal caps service fees at 15% at Live Nation-owned amphitheaters, opens those venues to rival promoters and ticketers, and sets up a $280 million fund for participating states, according to Rolling Stone. It's still awaiting Tunney Act approval from U.S. District Judge Arun Subramanian, the same review where Dorfman filed his objections.
None of it reaches Tuesday's checkout screen. A $1.72 overcharge and a fee cap at amphitheaters matter, but they don't touch a $405 face value at a stadium. Live Nation has long argued that artists and teams set prices and it just sells the tickets. That defense is weaker on fees and market power. On face value, artists and their teams, working with promoters, largely do make the call, which puts the question back on Kahan.
What comes next
The Reserved by Spotify presale opens Wednesday, November 11 at 9 a.m. local time, and the general onsale follows Thursday, November 12 at noon local. Those sales will show whether prices hold, move or open up more of the cheap seats some fans found Tuesday.
On Beacon Hill, the Massachusetts House pulled Healey's resale cap out of a supplemental budget bill in October, though similar language is still being negotiated on a separate track. Judge Subramanian's Tunney Act ruling and the states' remedies phase are still pending. Each of those fights targets a real problem: scalpers, fees, monopoly power.
What none of them targets is the number fans keep posting screenshots of. Kahan built his ticketing reputation on keeping tickets out of scalpers' hands. Tuesday's presale asked a harder question of him and of the artists who followed him into the resale fight: if fans are priced out at the box office, does it matter who they would have lost to on the resale market?








