The fight over D.C.’s ticket resale cap now has a new set of voices in court.

On Nov. 13, ten organizations representing musicians, actors, songwriters, managers, agents and fans filed an amicus brief in National Association of Ticketing Professionals v. District of Columbia, which is before U.S. District Judge Carl J. Nichols. They support the District and oppose the brokers’ request for a preliminary injunction that would block the RESALE Act before it takes effect.

Those filing in support include:

  • the American Federation of Musicians

  • Artist Rights Alliance

  • Fan Alliance

  • Future of Music Coalition

  • Music Artists Coalition

  • Music Managers Forum-US

  • the Recording Academy

  • National Independent Talent Organization (NITO)

  • SAG-AFTRA

  • Songwriters of North America

Katherine Van Dyck of KVD Strategies wrote the brief. It was filed with a consent motion, which means no party objected.

The plaintiffs are the National Association of Ticketing Professionals and two of its broker members, ASC and Stage Front. The brief points out more than once that the association used to be called the National Association of Ticket Brokers. A separate challenge, Ticket Policy Forum v. District of Columbia, which includes TickPick as a plaintiff, is moving alongside it in the same court.

What the law does

The Restricting Egregious Scalping Against Live Entertainment (RESALE) Amendment Act:

  • caps resale at 110% of a ticket’s original price

  • caps secondary exchange fees at 10% of the original price

  • requires resale listings to show the original price

  • bans speculative listings and bots

  • requires large resellers to register

  • lets the Mayor raise or lower the cap through rulemaking starting Jan. 1, 2028

The brokers say the law will force them to sell at a loss, push them out of the District, send fans to riskier channels and increase fraud. The support briefing reply comes down to one line from Van Dyck: “the harm they claim is the loss of the very markups the D.C. Council set out to stop.”

From Dickens to the Eras Tour

The brief starts in 1867, when Charles Dickens was on an American reading tour. Dickens wrote then that “it is impossible to keep out speculators who immediately sell at a premium.” From there it moves to:

  • Broadway’s “ice” scandal in 1964

  • the Rolling Stones’ failed ticket lottery in 1972

  • Bruce Springsteen’s 1980 complaint that “[t]ickets should go to the fans, not the scalpers”

The history is there for a legal reason. Van Dyck argues that resale caps have “almost universally survived” constitutional challenges since the end of the Lochner era. Her main precedent is Gold v. DiCarlo, a 1964 decision in which a three-judge panel upheld New York’s cap on resale markups and the Supreme Court summarily affirmed. A summary affirmance binds lower courts on the questions it decided, so the brief says the plaintiffs are asking Judge Nichols to “Lochner-ize regulation of the ticketing industry.”

The brief also says the brokers’ own industry has struggled to explain what separates it from old-fashioned scalping. It quotes a 2019 blog post by TickPick’s founder, who defined scalping as resale on or near the venue’s premises. By that definition, location is the only difference between scalpers and TickPick. In the same post he described “ticket brokers, ticket scalpers, and other middlemen like myself.”

“Plaintiffs Are Brokers, Not Fans”

The plaintiffs’ filing talks about fans who need “a way into sold-out shows and a way out of tickets they cannot use.” The brief answers by pointing to who actually sells on secondary exchanges:

  • 70–80% of listings come from brokers, according to several estimates, including TickPick’s founder.

  • The GAO found an average secondary markup of 74%.

  • A New York Attorney General study of six brokers found average markups of 49%, ranging from 15% to 118%.

  • NITO’s own survey of 65 shows found an average markup of 91%.

  • From 2013 to 2015, twelve brokers each bought more than $3 million in Ticketmaster tickets for New York-area events, and that counts only purchases made with American Express cards.

On the argument that brokers need big wins to cover losses on weaker shows, the brief says the risk is one they chose, which “is why they are called ‘speculators.’”

The Ticketmaster argument

The most notable section of the brief responds to the reseller lobby’s strongest talking point: that capping resale but not primary prices entrenches Ticketmaster.

Van Dyck answers with the record from U.S. v. Live Nation:

  • In April 2026, a jury found that Ticketmaster willfully acquired or maintained monopoly power in primary ticketing for major concert venues.

  • The jury found overcharges of $1.72 per ticket.

  • The evidence showed Ticketmaster’s market share has been “well over 80%” since 2017.

That monopoly is built on exclusive contracts with venues, before any fan buys a ticket. By the time a broker resells a ticket, the venue has already picked its primary ticketer and the first buyer has already paid that ticketer’s fees. The brief also notes that plaintiff ASC resells tickets on Ticketmaster’s own resale marketplace. Its conclusion: “Clearly, brokers are not competitors who discipline Ticketmaster. They are its customers, both as buyers and as sellers.”

The brief adds that uncapped resale may help Ticketmaster. It cites the FTC’s pending complaint, which alleges Ticketmaster can collect “three sets of fees on the same ticket” when it resells a ticket it originally sold.

The evidence the brief puts in front of the court

The brief comes with one sworn declaration, from Van Dyck herself. In it she states, “under penalty of perjury,” that each of the ten exhibits is “a true and accurate copy” of testimony from the D.C. Council’s Committee on Public Works and Operations hearing record for October 22, 2025.

That’s a deliberate strategy. The brief didn’t produce new witnesses. They put the legislative record in front of the court and argue that the Council had already heard all of this and made its choice. Here is what each exhibit says.

Exhibit A — Catherine Ferrando, Black Cat

The Black Cat has operated in D.C. since 1993, and Ferrando’s testimony gives the most concrete local examples:

logo

Subscribe to our premium content to read the rest.

Become a paying subscriber to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Upgrade

Already a subscriber? Sign in

Recommended for you

View all
caret-right